Joe's Picks

Cardigans That Earn Their Wardrobe Space

0 items

Joe's Top Picks

Button Cardigans Worth a Place in the Rotation WHITE AND WARREN White & Warren Superfine Cashmere Button Cardigan Sweater in Buttercream Jump to section ↓

$59.00 WHITE AND WARREN

Cable Knit Cardigans That Hold Their Shape MANLY Men's Retro Casual Cable Knit Zipper Sweater Cardigan MTAITO Jump to section ↓

$85.95 MANLY

Open Front Cardigans That Punch Above Their Weight W CONCEPT (US) Linda Modal Blend Cardigan Jump to section ↓

$146.00 W CONCEPT (US)

Regular Fit Cardigans That Actually Fit Right STUARTS LONDON (US &AMP; CANADA) Pringle of Scotland Cardigan - Mushroom Jump to section ↓

$130.00 STUARTS LONDON (US &AMP; CANADA)

Relaxed Cardigans That Actually Fit Right FARMRIO Off-White Crochet d Flower Knit Cardigan, OFF Jump to section ↓

$348.00 FARMRIO

Slim Fit Cardigans Cut to Sit Properly MARIMEKKO Puhaltaa Unikko Knitted cardigan Jump to section ↓

$425.00 MARIMEKKO

Zip Cardigans That Actually Earn Their Keep HARVEY NICHOLS US DRLE DE Monsieur Le Cardigan Aprs-sport Wool-blend Cardigan - Cream Jump to section ↓

$309.12 HARVEY NICHOLS US

Button Cardigans Worth a Place in the Rotation

The button cardigan gets dismissed too often as something your grandfather wore and we think that's a mistake worth correcting. Done right, it's one of the more useful layering pieces in a wardrobe. It works open over a shirt like a casual jacket. It works closed on its own. It moves between smart and relaxed without announcing the transition. The problem is that most of them get the details wrong. The buttons are cheap. The ribbing loses its shape after three washes. The yarn pills before the season is out. We've been looking specifically at options where the construction holds up, the fit doesn't swamp the shoulders, and the collar sits properly whether you've got a shirt underneath or nothing at all. Merino and lambswool are our preferred yarns here. Neutral colors get the most rotation but we've included a few that reward a bit more confidence. These are the ones that earn a permanent place in the drawer.

WHITE AND WARREN White & Warren Superfine Cashmere Button Cardigan Sweater in Buttercream $59.00 WHITE AND WARREN

EILEEN FISHER Mohair Plush Melange Crew Neck Cardigan $348.00 EILEEN FISHER

WHITE FOX BOUTIQUE US Cozy Vibes Knit Cardigan Chocolate $74.99 WHITE FOX BOUTIQUE US

ZEAGOO Long Sleeve Choker Top Lightweight Vee Cardigan Sweater - Yellow L- $21.89 ZEAGOO

THE LUXURY CLOSET Marina Rinaldi Blue Stripe Stretch Knit Cardigan $159.00 THE LUXURY CLOSET

THE LUXURY CLOSET Carolina Herrera Pink Wool Knit Button Front Cardigan $211.00 THE LUXURY CLOSET

FARMRIO Toucan Crochet Cardigan, OFF $248.00 FARMRIO

CLOTHING SHOP ONLINE Harriton - M - Men's Pilbloc V - Neck Button Cardigan Sweater - Grey Heather - $35.51 CLOTHING SHOP ONLINE

HARVEY NICHOLS US Acne Studios Kradi Textured Knitted Cardigan - Beige $283.36 HARVEY NICHOLS US

HARVEY NICHOLS US Good American Knit Cardigan - Black $199.64 HARVEY NICHOLS US

RENT THE RUNWAY Ulla Johnson Liza Cardigan Multicolored-cream-print $234.00 RENT THE RUNWAY

SHOEMALL.COM Masseys Puff Sleeve Sweater Cardigan Black Sweaters X $25.00 SHOEMALL.COM

Cable Knit Cardigans That Hold Their Shape

Cable knit cardigans have a specific failure mode and it happens fast. You wear them a few times, wash them once, and the structure collapses. The cables go soft, the shoulders drop, and what started as a considered layering piece now looks like something you found at the back of a closet. We've seen it too many times to ignore. The ones worth buying are built differently. Tighter gauge yarn, construction that accounts for real wear, and cables that stay defined after the first dozen washes. We've been focused specifically on cardigans that work over a shirt for something that reads as smart without trying too hard, and alone on weekends without looking underdressed. That range of use is harder to find than it should be. These are also pieces that age well when they're made right. A good cable knit cardigan two years from now should look better than it did on day one. These ones will.

MANLY Men's Retro Casual Cable Knit Zipper Sweater Cardigan MTAITO $85.95 MANLY

HELLO MOLLY (US) Cozying Up Cardigan Purple $75.95 HELLO MOLLY (US)

ZEAGOO Zeagoo Long Sleeve Lace Cable Knit Sweater Open Front Cardigan Button Loose Shirts - White L- $29.90 ZEAGOO

HELLOMOLLY US Winter Love Story Cable Knit Cardigan Grey $59.95 HELLOMOLLY US

PETAL PUP US Miffy Zip Through Cardigan $99.00 PETAL PUP US

THE LUXURY CLOSET Polo Ralph Lauren Purple Mini Cable Knit Button Front Cardigan Yrs $206.00 THE LUXURY CLOSET

HARVEY NICHOLS US Never Fully Dressed Stud-embellished Knit Cardigan - Light Blue - M M $100.46 HARVEY NICHOLS US

SHOPBOP Sporty & Rich Cable Knit Cashmere Cardigan Camel $290.00 SHOPBOP

MEMOI Kids Cozy Oversized Cable-Knit Cardigan Sweater - - Pink $48.00 MEMOI

ZEAGOO Zeagoo Long Sleeve Lace Cable Knit Sweater Open Front Cardigan Button Loose Shirts - Black S $29.90 ZEAGOO

WILD OAK BOUTIQUE Keaton Knit Cardigan $59.00 WILD OAK BOUTIQUE

SHOPBOP Polo Ralph Lauren Cotton Cable Long Sleeve Cardigan New Litchfield Blue $228.00 SHOPBOP

Open Front Cardigans That Punch Above Their Weight

The open front cardigan is one of those pieces that most men write off as too casual or too shapeless before they've ever tried a good one. That's a mistake. Worn over a simple tee or a light oxford shirt, the right open front cardigan adds weight and intention to an outfit without the formality of a blazer or the bulk of a coat. It fills the gap between dressed and relaxed better than almost anything else. We've been focused specifically on versions that have structure through the shoulder, a length that works tucked over trousers as well as with denim, and yarns that drape rather than sag. Color matters too. The ones in here go beyond grey and oatmeal without tipping into territory you'll regret by next season. These are cardigans that work harder than their price suggests and look better than most men expect. The open front format is doing more work than it gets credit for.

W CONCEPT (US) Linda Modal Blend Cardigan $146.00 W CONCEPT (US)

HARVEY NICHOLS US Sister Jane Lily Leopard-print Brushed Woven Cardigan - S $54.74 HARVEY NICHOLS US

HARVEY NICHOLS US Kitri Dionne Striped Crochet-knit Cardigan - Multicoloured $161.00 HARVEY NICHOLS US

SELDOM SEEN STYLES Boho Knit Cardigan with Pockets $64.95 SELDOM SEEN STYLES

WHITE AND WARREN White & Warren Cashmere Open Front Cardigan Sweater in Grey Heather $99.00 WHITE AND WARREN

SHOEMALL.COM Masseys Open Knit Cardigan Bone Knit Tops X $23.99 SHOEMALL.COM

W CONCEPT (US) Wave Scarf Cardigan, Pink $87.00 W CONCEPT (US)

HARVEY NICHOLS US Pleats Please Issey Miyake Pleated Woven Cardigan - Navy $405.72 HARVEY NICHOLS US

SHOEMALL.COM Masseys Open Knit Cardigan Black Knit Tops $23.99 SHOEMALL.COM

DAILY SALE, INC. Ladies Crochet Cardigan Sweater $39.00 DAILY SALE, INC.

HELLOMOLLY US Winter Solace Knit Cardigan Red $59.95 HELLOMOLLY US

EILEEN FISHER Gossamer Organic Cotton Cardigan $125.40 EILEEN FISHER

Regular Fit Cardigans That Actually Fit Right

The regular fit cardigan has a sizing problem that nobody talks about enough. Too many of them are cut with so much room through the body that they end up looking shapeless on anyone who isn't built like a linebacker. Others go the opposite direction and bill themselves as regular when they're really just a slim fit with extra buttons. Neither works. What actually works is a cardigan with a clean shoulder seam, enough room through the chest to layer comfortably over a shirt, and a body length that hits the right place on the hip. That sounds simple. It isn't. We've been through a lot of cardigans to find the ones that genuinely understand what regular fit should mean in practice. These are the ones that work over a Oxford cloth button down, look considered with dark trousers, and don't require you to size up or down just to make them sit right. This is what the category should look like.

STUARTS LONDON (US &AMP; CANADA) Pringle of Scotland Cardigan - Mushroom $130.00 STUARTS LONDON (US &AMP; CANADA)

DRESTIGE US Boss cardigan zestart $214.70 DRESTIGE US

CERQULAR Tommy Hilfiger Striped Cardigan - Large Red Cotton $40.19 CERQULAR

FALCONERI Falconeri Ultrasoft Cashmere zippered cardigan Man Stone $495.00 FALCONERI

FLORALKINI Letter D Chain Print Front Button V Neck Knit Cardigan - S Pink $50.99 FLORALKINI

MANLY Men's Fashion Stand Collar Solid Striped Long Sleeve Knit Cardigan Z $82.95 MANLY

DRESTIGE US Jucca Cardigan - $265.05 DRESTIGE US

FALCONERI Falconeri Cardigan with Buttons $435.00 FALCONERI

MANLY Men's Solid Knitted Waffle Stand Collar Zipper Cardigan Y $54.95 MANLY

DRESTIGE US Cardigan Man Thinking Mu Creed fishermans navy $304.95 DRESTIGE US

TV STORE ONLINE A Christmas Story Leg Lamp Button Up Cardigan Ugly Holiday Sweater $44.95 TV STORE ONLINE

DRESTIGE US Selected Homme knit crochet polo cardigan - oatmeal secret $206.15 DRESTIGE US

Relaxed Cardigans That Actually Fit Right

The cardigan has an image problem that comes entirely from bad proportions. Too boxy and it swamps you. Too fitted and it looks like you borrowed it from a smaller man. The relaxed cardigan sits in a specific middle ground that a lot of brands talk about and very few actually nail. What we're looking for is a shoulder seam that lands right, a body length that works untucked over a collar or layered under a jacket, and enough ease through the chest that you can actually move. The yarn matters too. Something with real weight that doesn't pill after three wears and doesn't lose its shape by February. We've been through a lot of cardigans that photograph well and wear badly. The ones here do neither of those things. They're the kind of piece you reach for without thinking, which is the whole point. A well fitting relaxed cardigan is harder to find than it should be. These are the ones worth finding.

FARMRIO Off-White Crochet d Flower Knit Cardigan, OFF $348.00 FARMRIO

FARMRIO Off-White Mixed Lace Stitch Cardigan, OFF $190.00 FARMRIO

FARMRIO Mixed Nature Knit Cardigan, NATURE SAND $198.00 FARMRIO

DRESTIGE US Cardigan Selected Homme ls cody knit relaxed cardigan - demitasse $216.60 DRESTIGE US

GIFTOMORY Stripes of Love Cozy Cardigan Gift $85.50 GIFTOMORY

FARMRIO Cream Embroidered Flowers Buttoned Knit Cardigan, CREAM $360.00 FARMRIO

EILEEN FISHER Peruvian Organic Cotton Crimp Hooded Cardigan $149.40 EILEEN FISHER

THE LUXURY CLOSET Dolce & Gabbana Grey Chunky Knit Button Front Cardigan $217.00 THE LUXURY CLOSET

THE LUXURY CLOSET Kith Blue Intarsia Cotton Knit Button Front Cardigan $163.00 THE LUXURY CLOSET

HARVEY NICHOLS US Lisa Yang Lunea Cashmere Cardigan - Grey - $444.36 HARVEY NICHOLS US

HARVEY NICHOLS US American Vintage Damsville Knit Cardigan - Burgundy $83.72 HARVEY NICHOLS US

HARVEY NICHOLS US DRLE DE Monsieur Le Cardigan Monogramme Striped Terry Cardigan - Khaki $218.96 HARVEY NICHOLS US

Slim Fit Cardigans Cut to Sit Properly

The slim fit cardigan has a fitting problem that most brands refuse to acknowledge. Too many of them are cut with so much room through the body that they look shapeless over a shirt, and too many others are cropped so aggressively that they work only with very specific outfits. Neither is much use in a real wardrobe. What actually works is a cardigan with a clean, fitted silhouette through the chest and waist that still moves properly and sits flat when buttoned. One that you can wear over a collared shirt without the collar bunching underneath, and that looks equally at home with tailored trousers or dark denim. We have been specifically looking for fine to midweight options where the cut does the heavy lifting rather than relying on the novelty of the color or some unnecessary design detail. These cardigans are slim without being tight, polished without being precious, and useful enough to earn permanent space in your rotation.

MARIMEKKO Puhaltaa Unikko Knitted cardigan $425.00 MARIMEKKO

CAMI Kimbra Pearl Cardigan Shadow Stripe $245.00 CAMI

ZEAGOO 🔥Limited Days & Lowest Price Chic V-neck Knitted Three-piece Set Crop Vest and Sweater Cardigan & Solid Wide Leg Pants - Grey $29.99 ZEAGOO

MARIMEKKO Arvaus Unikko Knit cardigan $395.00 MARIMEKKO

VOGHION GLOBAL Men’s Fleece-Lined Stand Collar Knit Cardigan Slim Fit Zip-Up Sweater For Winter Sizes M- $24.47 VOGHION GLOBAL

THE WEBSTER Micro Stripe Long Sleeve Cardigan Palm Green Stripe $158.00 THE WEBSTER

RAMY BROOK Raven Textured Stripe Button Front Cardigan in Coffee stripe $245.00 RAMY BROOK

VOGHION GLOBAL Year-End Clearance Cardigan Solid Color Zipper Sweater Versatile Knitwear Autumn Winter Hot-Selling Slim Fit Jacket Men $24.98 VOGHION GLOBAL

CERQULAR Polo Ribbed Cardigan $88.40 CERQULAR

SELDOM SEEN STYLES Cardigan Elara V-Neck Hollow Knit $38.00 SELDOM SEEN STYLES

VERONICA BEARD Veronica Beard Lira Pointelle Cardigan Ecru $149.00 VERONICA BEARD

VOGHION GLOBAL Double-Zip Knit Cardigan Slim-Fit V-Neck Pullover For Men M-, GreyBlackBeige $22.15 VOGHION GLOBAL

Zip Cardigans That Actually Earn Their Keep

The zip cardigan gets written off more often than it deserves, usually because the wrong version of it exists in too many wardrobes. Thin fabric, a plasticky zipper, a fit that goes shapeless after four washes. That version deserves the skepticism. The right zip cardigan, though, is one of the more useful layering pieces a man can own. It goes over a shirt and under a jacket without adding bulk. It works on a Saturday when you are not trying to dress up but you are also not not trying. It takes the place of a blazer in situations where a blazer would be too much. We have been looking specifically for options with real weight to the fabric, a zip that sits flush when closed, and a collar that behaves. Nothing with a logo where the chest pocket should be. These are the ones that pull their weight every single time you reach for them.

HARVEY NICHOLS US DRLE DE Monsieur Le Cardigan Aprs-sport Wool-blend Cardigan - Cream $309.12 HARVEY NICHOLS US